Constructive Criticism

by Patricia Morgan on April 16, 2010

“I have some constructive criticism for you.” Are you ready? Are you bracing yourself? Are you eager for the next sentence?”  People with high resilience manage unwelcome critcism.

Criticism can feel like being shame or belittled.

Many people have walked away feeling crushed, ruined, cut off at the knees, humbled, humiliated or plain cheesed off after recieving so-called constructive criticism. There are those who are totally against using any form of criticism and then there are the critical hardliners who say, “A real friend will tell you the naked truth.”

Some people have been so wounded in their youth by constant putdowns, sarcasm and criticism that they do exactly the same to others or go to the other extreme of never uttering a word of disagreement. Some people seem to be gifted with a critical mind and perspective. Their gift to the world is a logical critique that forewarns of problems. But where is the balance?

Dr. Sidney Simon’s classic little book, Negative Criticism, provides a filter or series of questions to ask before we criticize another:

1. Is this the right time?

2. Can she or he do anything about the situation or behaviour?

3. Has she or he heard this before? Is this new information?

4. Am I sure that none of my own hangups are involved?

5. Is it possible that this person needs more encouragement, than anything else?

What unwelcome criticism have you recieved? How did you handle it?

Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: